Hey Joanne! Thank you so much for the review =-)
The Shark Tails are almost always the smaller size (which is still generous) - they have been for many many years. There's been a few times the bigger ones have come through but they're not achievable all the time - we've only ever gotten them once or twice and it's completely outside of our control. We pay by weight for the tail, so when you've gotten the bigger ones we've probably lost money on those bags!
The norm is the regular size that goes into the packs regularly - the bigger size is the rarity and we have been a bit apprehensive to use them in any orders due to both cost and to give a false impression of the size of the regular Shark Tail size which sadly seems to have happened here.
It's near impossible to sell this treat by weight, though, as they're all different and to cut this treat down after its dehydrated is too much labour!
Very sorry and I hope you understand!